A shareholder can sue a director in some circumstances. In England and Wales, the first question is who suffered the harm. If a director misused company money, the claim usually belongs to the company. If the director broke a promise made to you personally, you may have your own claim. And if the way the company is being run has unfairly harmed your interests as a shareholder, you may be able to bring an unfair prejudice petition. Each route serves a different purpose. legislation.gov.uk
Who can claim if a director has cost the company money?
Directors owe their general duties under the Companies Act 2006 to the company. Those duties include using their powers for proper purposes, exercising independent judgement, taking reasonable care and managing conflicts of interest. A financial loss alone does not establish a breach. The circumstances of the decision and what the director knew at the time matter. GOV.UK
Suppose a director sells a company vehicle worth £30,000 to a business they own for £10,000. The £20,000 shortfall is a loss to the company. If you hold 25% of its shares, that does not give you a personal claim for £5,000. Where a fall in share value or dividends simply reflects a loss the company can claim from the same director, the shareholder generally cannot recover that amount personally. This is known as the reflective loss rule. supremecourt.uk
What if the company will not take action?
If the director involved also controls the board, the company may be unwilling to pursue the matter. A shareholder may then consider a derivative claim. This allows a shareholder to pursue a claim on the company’s behalf for an actual or proposed act or omission involving a director’s negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust. Any damages recovered belong to the company. legislation.gov.uk
A shareholder who starts a derivative claim must apply for the court’s permission to continue it. The court considers, among other things, whether the shareholder is acting in good faith and how important the claim would be to someone acting to promote the company’s success. Valid authorisation or ratification of the conduct can require the court to refuse permission. In the vehicle example, the valuation, the director’s disclosure of their interest and the record of who approved the sale could all matter. legislation.gov.uk
When can a shareholder bring a personal claim?
Start with the promise or obligation you say the director breached. For example, a director may also be a co-owner who agreed in their own name to buy your shares for a specified price. If payment falls due and remains unpaid, you may have a contractual claim against that person. The agreement, the identity of the buyer and any conditions attached to payment will determine your position.
Check the signature page as well as the wording of the agreement. A director may have signed on behalf of the company. Establishing who made the promise can save you from pursuing the wrong party. supremecourt.uk
Could a minority shareholder seek a buyout?
In an owner-managed business, the shareholder’s main concern may be whether they can leave on fair terms. Under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, a member can petition the court where the conduct of the company’s affairs unfairly prejudices their interests as a member. A petition can also concern a proposed company act that would have that effect. legislation.gov.uk
For example, two founders may have invested on the shared understanding that both would manage the business. If one is later excluded from decisions while the other uses company funds for personal benefit, the original understanding and the subsequent payments may both be relevant. Exclusion from management alone does not establish unfair prejudice. What the founders agreed, how the business operated and how the conduct affected the shareholder all need examining. Stephensons Solicitors LLP
If the petition succeeds, the court has a wide choice of remedies under section 996. It can order other shareholders or the company to buy the petitioner’s shares, or regulate how the company’s affairs are run in future. A buyout is one possible outcome. The court decides what relief fits the circumstances. legislation.gov.uk
What should you prepare before speaking to a solicitor?
Write down what happened, when you learned about it and what you want to achieve. Recovering money for the company, stopping a proposed transaction and negotiating the sale of your shares are different objectives. Being clear about yours helps a solicitor assess the likely cost and value of each option.
Gather the documents you already lawfully hold, particularly the articles of association, any shareholders’ agreement, relevant resolutions and correspondence. Identify any upcoming vote, sale or transfer and give the solicitor its exact date. If the transaction has yet to take place, there may be options worth considering before it goes ahead. legislation.gov.uk
Speak to Greystone about a shareholder dispute
If you are concerned about a director’s use of company assets, your exclusion from decisions or the terms of a proposed buyout, Greystone’s commercial litigation solicitors can review your position and discuss negotiation or court action. Call 01582 343 453 or contact our Luton office to discuss your next step. Solicitors in Luton



