Disputed invoice: what to do when a customer challenges a charge
When a customer raises a disputed invoice, ask them to identify the charge they challenge, explain why and confirm how much of the bill they accept. Check their objection against the order and your delivery records, then give them a date for a written response. If only part of the invoice is in dispute, ask whether they can pay the agreed balance while you investigate.
For businesses in England and Wales, the next step depends on what the customer says went wrong. A duplicate charge may take minutes to correct. A claim that your work caused the customer a loss needs a closer look before you pursue debt collection.
What should you say when a customer disputes an invoice?
Acknowledge the concern promptly. A useful first response gives the customer one person to deal with and asks for the information you need. For example:
Thank you for raising this. Could you confirm which items on invoice 1048 you’re querying and what you expected us to charge? I’ll check the order with our team and come back to you by Thursday. If you agree the rest of the invoice, please let me know when we can expect payment of that amount.
Read the customer’s explanation before sending another payment reminder. If they say someone in your business agreed to a discount, speak to that person. An email sent after the original order may explain why the customer expected a different price.
Which records will help resolve the dispute?
Start with the question the customer has raised. Sending the one document that answers it can save both sides a lengthy exchange.
| What the customer disputes | What to check |
|---|---|
| “We agreed a lower price.” | Compare the invoice with the accepted quote, including any discount, currency or later price change. |
| “We didn’t order that extra work.” | Check who requested the change, what they authorised and whether you agreed an additional charge. |
| “Part of the order never arrived.” | Compare the quantities on the order and delivery note. Check whether you sent the goods in separate consignments. |
| “The work wasn’t up to standard.” | Review the agreed specification, the customer’s description of the problem, any photographs and your team’s record of the work. |
Once you have checked the records, explain your conclusion in writing. If you made a billing error, identify it and send the correction. If you consider the charge payable, set out how you calculated it and share the relevant evidence. Give the customer a contact and a date for following up.
Can you collect the undisputed part of an invoice?
Ask the customer to identify any amount they accept. For example, if they agree a £2,400 printing charge but query a £180 delivery fee, ask them to pay the £2,400 by the agreed payment date while you check who authorised delivery. Confirm in writing how you will allocate the payment and what remains to be resolved.
Take particular care if the customer offers a smaller sum “in full and final settlement” or says they have a claim against you for their own losses. Before accepting the offer, clarify whether they intend the payment to settle the whole dispute. If the amount at stake is significant, seek advice on the proposed terms.
What if you and the customer still disagree?
Consider what a workable settlement would look like. If the complaint concerns a defect, the customer may value a repair or replacement more than a discount. If you agree a solution, record what each side will do, the deadline and which charges the agreement settles.
If direct discussions stall, mediation gives both sides an opportunity to explore a settlement with an independent mediator. Before starting a court claim in England and Wales, check which pre-action rules apply. For an ordinary dispute between limited companies where no specific protocol applies, the parties should explain their positions, exchange the key documents and consider settlement. If your business is claiming a debt from a sole trader, the Pre-Action Protocol for Debt Claims generally applies, subject to its exceptions. Justice UK
How can you prevent the same invoice dispute happening again?
Use the reason for the dispute to decide what to change. If the customer queried an extra charge, agree the price of changes in writing before doing the work. If they could not match an invoice to a delivery, include their order reference and delivery date when you bill them. Send the invoice promptly and give the customer a named contact for queries.
Speak to Greystone about a disputed invoice
If a customer alleges defective work, claims compensation or refuses payment after you have provided evidence, Greystone’s commercial litigation solicitors can review the contract and advise you on negotiation and debt recovery. Call 01582 343 453 or contact our Luton office to discuss the disputed charge. Solicitors in Luton



